Decision in process elsevier accept.
Elsevier 저널 논문 심사 .
Decision in process elsevier accept Prefer reading? View the related Improve the chances of your manuscript’s acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. You don’t worry about change date with same status. Click the 'Review Time' link to see to see the average number of weeks it takes for a manuscript to reach first and final decision over the last several years. If your manuscript is not accepted for publication in your chosen journal, you may receive an offer to transfer your submission to a more suitable journal, via Elsevier's Article Transfer Service (ATS). 6% wished to make the final decision alone, and only 9. The decision will be guided by the reviewer recommendations but the Editor is not necessarily bound by them. I was notified that my manuscript has been accepted. The result of this assessment is known as a desk decision. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? When editors make a final decision on a manuscript, the decision and reviewer comments are sent in a letter to the corresponding author. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? Explore Elsevier's Decision sciences journals and stay up-to-date with the latest research and insights from top authors in the field. However, it is sometimes tricky to draw a clear line between intentional copying and unintentional lack of references when using somebody else’s ideas and/or wording. Elsevier plays no part in this decision. After 18 days the status changed to "Decision in Process". This section breaks down the typical peer review process by discussing the steps from submission to the selection of reviewers by the editors. For example, if the journal requires a second copy of the revised manuscript with tracked changes, or responses to review comments. Decision in Process means that the associate editor has gone through the peer review comments, arrived at a decision on the manuscript based on the comments, and then conveyed their decision to the Editor-in-Chief. 편집자가 투고자에게 수정을 요구한 상태. This decision could either be an acceptance, rejection, or request for revisions. Save time: Easily find other journals using suggestions based on input from journal editors, insights from our Scientific Editors, and matching algorithms. Already in 1992, Banerjee developed a model that “analysed a sequential decision model in which each decision maker looks at the decisions made by previous decision makers in taking her own decision” (Banerjee, 1992, p. 797). This is usually journal-dependent, e. This status means that peer reviewers have finished their review and sent their reports to the chief editor/editor-in-chief, but the final decision has not yet been In Elsevier, particularly, before this happens, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. 下面就这个问题，详细聊一聊SCI论文投递完成后，不同阶段投稿系统中的状态一栏的提示 Journal Finder is a tool that uses a machine learning algorithm to recommend Elsevier journals that match the scope of your manuscript. The editor ultimately decides whether to accept or reject the article. It means that the editorial board is in the process of making the final decision about your paper. Guidelines for reviewers 2. How long does the ‘decision in process’ take? There’s no specific time frame for this; the time may vary depending on the journal and the field. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? Often, the decision taken by a journal on the manuscript in its original form, that is, before it is revised, is referred to as the "first decision. What does it mean? Thanks in advance. To give the author another opportunity to accept a Transfer Offer, use Rescind Decision and then make a new Transfer decision. If there is a decision before it was sent to reviewers, it usually means a desk-rejection. But how does the editor actually take the decision on a manuscript? This article explains the sequence of events that lead from peer review to editorial decision making: how the AE procures the completed reviews, assesses them, and finally comes to a decision on whether to I submitted my paper to an Elsevier Journal on 22 Feb 2018. They promised that the review process will be expedited as it's unusual for a manuscript to have a "with editor" status for two weeks. Introduction. In accepting an invitation to review, your role is to provide an assessment that will assist the Editor in making a decision on the paper. Please let me know the meaning of 'Decision in process. This stage can last from a couple of minutes to several days. For all subsequent steps, please check Next steps for publishing your article: What to expect after acceptance. e. The following decision types are available: Reject; Major revision; Minor revision; Accept; Decisions are communicated to the corresponding author in a formal letter, along with reviewer feedback and any other requirements from the While less common, these factors can contribute to the dynamic nature of the peer review process. Blog com foco em política, atualidades e cultura | Pernambuco. In Elsevier, particularly, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. If you receive major or minor revisions, you will have When a journal displays the “decision in process” status, it means that the editorial board is in the process of making the final decision about your paper. Just want to know what you think based on You can track your accepted article using Elsevier’s Article Tracking service. Later, on October 19, it was ‘Under editor evaluation’ and on October 22, ‘Decision in process’. 13. The status have been "With editor" since a month. Why is now taking such a long time? I have submitted a manuscript to a journal on September after few days the status changed to under review and after 5 months the it changed to all required reviews are completed and immediately to decision in process. If you accept this offer, your manuscript files will be transferred with no need to upload the same files again (additional files may be required depending on the journal). An example of how the status date might change but the status remains as "decision in progress" is if the journal is set up so that the editorial board member makes a decision, the decision is forwarded to the editor-in-chief, and the editor-in Stage 4: Decision. To get right into it, your (seniors’) understanding of the ‘Awaiting EiC Decision’ in ScholarOne's Manuscript Central (called ‘Decision in Process’ in some other systems) is To help authors find an alternative journal, we have our Elsevier Article Transfer Service (ATS) in place for the majority of our journals. ^ I hope that's true. I normally take <2 days for clear rejections. OSJ broad scope provides a platform to publish original research in all areas of sciences, including interdisciplinary and replication studies Please note the policy only refers to the writing process, Elsevier does not permit the use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools to create or alter images in submitted manuscripts. You can modify the cover letter and consider However, if your paper was "With editor" and then "Decision in process" without "Under review," it might be a situation that, the AE does not think your paper is not enough qualified to be reviewed. Is long period a good or bad sign? I do understand that you cannot have exact answer. Request Unregistered Reviewer: Opens an email form for you to enter details of reviewers, which you can then send to the Editorial Office to be registered. It then discusses the various players Elsevier’s Article Transfer Service will shorten your path to publication by suggesting journals that are more suitable for your paper, if your initial submission isn’t successful. Then the status changed to “Decision in process”. Proofing modes. If required, the editor Please note the policy only refers to the writing process, Elsevier does not permit the use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools to create or alter images in submitted manuscripts. ; Review the letter that is generated as it might require In Elsevier, particularly, before this happens, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. 1. If it is set up for your journal, ATS enables you to reject a manuscript from your journal, Editor Decision. The status “Decision in process” after “Under review” means that all the reviews have come in and the editor is evaluating your paper based on the reviewer’s comments. We, as editors of Matter, wanted to take the time to shed Understanding customized editorial statuses can help authors understand which stage a submission is at within the peer-review process. In particular, our team of dedicated in-house Scientific Editors ensures that transferred papers are sent for peer review at a select group of journals, and authors are given the chance to revise their paper. Setting this number higher than the current number of It is up to the editor whether to accept or reject. Many of Elsevier’s journals work with SSRN to provide you with an efficient, one click 'opt-in' process for the upload of your preprint manuscript to SSRN, one of the world’s largest preprint servers, with more journals joining regularly. Manuscripts move from "Required Reviews Complete" to "Decision in Progress" when the editor's ready to make a decision. I thought it is a desk rejection but shouldn’t the decision have been sent already? Why is it taking all that time to inform the corresponding author of the editor’s decision? Could I have Now, ‘Decision in process’ means that the AE has made a decision on the manuscript and has communicated this decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who will make the final decision on the manuscript. However, I have heard nothing from the journal for 3 weeks, though I assumed I would receive a response in a few days. The status changed to 'Under review' for 3 weeks and then turned to 'Under Editor Evaluation' around Christmas. Provisional accept Following peer review, [] How. 501st blue color code; pembroke pines charter high school This video covers the steps to take in Editorial Manager when setting the final disposition on a manuscript, following an "Accept" decision. This feedback allows reviewers to assess You can almost begin celebrating, but of course, it may be more pragmatic to hold on until you hear the final ‘accept. In any case, I wish you have a good result. Subscribe and get 6. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? Identify the determinants that influence the patient's decision-making process when deciding to accept or decline preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) in a given IVF cycle. I sent a gentle inquiry and was told that only one review is in and one was still outstanding. Once this status shows up, the author is generally informed of the editorial decision in a few days’ time. AE of an Elsevier journal. For example, Elsevier journals desk reject 30 to 50 percent of all submissions. After that, the EIC takes a call on whether you need to revise and resubmit or your article is rejected. Later, on August 29, it was ‘Under editor evaluation’. This may I sent a submission to an Elsevier Journal. 수정 후 게재(accept with minor revision)인 경우, 본문의 사소한 내용을 고친 뒤 별도의 심사 없이 논문이 게재된다. Completed - Accept/Reject When the status changed to “Decision in Process”, it meant that based on the peer review, the handling editor had made a decision on the manuscript. Completed - Accept/Reject Welcome to the Decision Sciences journals area of Elsevier. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? Manuscripts move from "Under review" to "Required Reviews Complete" when all the necessary reviews to make a decision have arrived. When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. By: Alison McGonagle-O’Connell, Marketing Manager, Aries Systems Corporation Once you’ve submitted a manuscript for publication in a journal, you may be anxious about your manuscript status. Based on the Heliyon Review Speed Feedback System, it takes editor 91. Does this mean that the editor has rejected the paper? If so, normally I should receive an e-mail. You may be asking: Decision in Process means that the associate editor has gone through the peer review comments, arrived at a decision on the manuscript based on the comments, and then conveyed their decision to the Editor-in-Chief. Editor’s Decision is final Referees advise the editor, who is responsible for the final decision to accept or reject the article. Completed - Accept/Reject 不要催，耐心等待就行。 系统显示的状态只是一个告知，告诉作者现在大概是什么阶段了，其实背后的工作是很细化的，一个Decision in process要包含好多事，有时候一个审稿人意见不同系统状态不变会直接再审对，或者编辑搞不清楚审稿人的意见正在挨个沟通，因为要给你一个准确统一的 After 2 months of peer review process, it is very difficult to say something about Elsevier journals the article will soon receive an editor's decision which either is reject or accept. Menu. After resubmitting my revised manuscript on 20th of June, the status changed to 'under review' after only 4 days and then after 6 days (on 30th of June) it changed to 'required reviews completed. The following decision types are available: Reject; Major revision; Minor I submitted a paper ages ago for Heliyon, which seemed to be a reputable journal to me. Normally, the editor decides the outcome after this. At this point, there’re two possible reasons: (1) at least one editor has submitted his recommendation/decision to the system or (2) the senior editor supervising the process (i. Elsevier’s Article Transfer Service will shorten your path to publication by suggesting journals that are more suitable for your paper, if your initial submission isn’t successful. The editor will then decide whether to accept your work as is, request minor or major revisions, or reject the paper due to unresolvable concerns. However, authors may appeal a rejection by sending an email notification to jognn@awhonn. If you are a confirmed co-author, you will only see submissions currently being processed, or with completed decisions. Good luck. If you are a seasoned reviewer looking to make certain you have dotted your “I”s and The average number of days between the date of manuscript submission and date of receiving the editorial acceptance decision. I submitted my paper to an Elsevier journal 5 weeks ago. It was rather an easy comment, so I resubmitted the case report after revision immediately. On May 28, it was ‘Under review’. some journals can move the status when one review has been submitted, while others might ask for 2 or 3 or more. Subscribe today. You will see what each decision type is and what it means for you and your article. How long this stage normally takes ? Please note: Subtitles are available in Spanish, French and Mandarin. There can be four possible outcomes: Accept; Reject In an Elsevier journal, after some long time, I looked at the status of my paper on the tracking system and I realized that one of the two reviewers did not even accept the review invitation. My case report, which was edited by Editage, received a minor revision request by a journal. " The first decision could either be a rejection without peer review or a request to revise and resubmit after peer review. This streamlines the process of 7. If you are not on EM, go to your journal homepage by searching for the journal's title in the ‘Find a journal’ section on the journal author's page and clicking on the journal name. 7. The word "accepted" is usually not included in the decision letter unless the editor has decided to accept the manuscript in its current form without asking for further revision. . Elsevier is a leading publisher in the field of social and political. When the decision is finalized you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. They may choose to decline the recommendation or ask for additional peer reviews before making a final decision. Depending on the journal, Proof Central may also allow you to view your corrected proof using a PDF generator ("PageCentral"), or it allows you to switch from online correction to an offline PDF annotation mode. Once the final requirements are fulfilled, the journal office will send a formal accept decision, and your manuscript will move on to production. In this case, however, the status went back to under review after I resubmitted. The decision as to whether your article is accepted or I submitted a research article in a Q1 journal of Elsevier on Oct 20, 2020. Finally, the editor in Chief finalizes the decision. The Editorial Office may also provide this letter to This section breaks down the typical peer review process by discussing the steps from submission to the selection of reviewers by the editors. SSRN also hosts thousands of preprints of papers published in non-Elsevier journals and elsewhere. I submitted a manuscript to an Elsevier journal over a year ago and the status remains “decision in process” for more than 8 months now. 3 weeks is pretty long for this. If it is set up for your journal, ATS Final decision: The editor has received the peer review reports and has made a final decision; Possible Decisions. Editor Decision. There is no reason to think that your paper will be rejected considering the fact In Elsevier, particularly, before this happens, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. After 1 day, the status changed to “With Editor”. Completed - Accept/Reject Now, ‘Decision in process’ means that the AE has made a decision on the manuscript and has communicated this decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who will make the final decision on the manuscript. Hello. The editors consider reviewer feedback and their own evaluation of the manuscript in order to reach a decision. How does an Editor change a Decision in Editorial Manager? Note that either option requires special permissions in EM, you may need to contact your editorial office or journal manager to complete the process. Decision in Process: The decision process may require some time since the editor needs to read the revised manuscript and the revisions/rebuttal from the author to make a decision. The "decision in process" is the editor choosing if the next step is acceptance, revision, or rejection. You will find the details of changes required and the deadline for your revision in the Decision Letter. I have done a submission to other journal some months before and the "with editor" process First of all, you have to wait for the minimum time to take final decision (that is generally 10-12 weeks for Elsevier). One of the reviewer submitted the report. ; Click the action View Reviews and Comments to see all completed reviews and editor decisions. Elsevier is currently publishing not only the time to 1st decision and publication but also the CiteScore, Impact Factor, and are an essential part of the publishing process, so we have created this resource for both new and experienced reviewers. Author Guide to the Publication Process (Post-Acceptance) Last updated on November 18, 2024 If you wish to find out more about aspects of the publication process, please see below for more information that may be of help to you, as well as who to contact should you require further assistance: 很不幸，一般来说，如果没有经历Reviewers invited（审稿人审稿）状态，直接进入Decision in process（决定）状态，说明编辑并没有将稿件分发给审稿人，而是自己直接做了决定，而这个决定一般是Reject（拒稿）。. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? I submitted an article in a scientific journal, after verification by the editor the status is changed (Awaiting Reviewer Scores), then after a month and a half, the status is changed again Now she has to read the comments (and likely look at your manuscript again to see if they comments are relevant), come to a decision, and write a corresponding letter to the author summarizing the comments and justifying the decision. This is your overall editor decision, and controls which decision While less common, these factors can contribute to the dynamic nature of the peer review process. Acceptance decisions are made by an academic editor (the Editor-in-Chief, a Guest Editor/Topic Editor/Collection Editor, or another suitable Editorial Board member). However, most journals normally take 4-8 weeks to review manuscripts. In an Elsevier journal, after some long time, I looked at the status of my paper on the tracking system and I realized that one of the two reviewers did not even accept the review invitation. If required, the editor may consult the editorial board at this stage. About the editorial process: Confirmation email: After confirming the transfer, you will receive an email from Elsevier with a copy of the confirmed transfer details. After submitting your decision, the 'Notify Author' page appears if your role has permission to draft the decision letter. I have submitted one study to an Elsevier journal around the end of November. Understanding customized editorial statuses can help authors understand which stage a submission is at within the peer-review process. In this blog, Elsevier provides rich and detailed articles about the submission and publication process. Based on the Applied Catalysis B: Environmental Review Speed Feedback System, it takes editor - days to accept manuscript. ; If you feel more reviews are need before making a decision, see How can an editor change the required number of reviews for a submission?. community and it is essential that the peer review process is impartial, objective and fair. After 2 months of peer review process, it is very difficult to say something about Elsevier journals the article will soon receive an editor's decision which either is reject or accept. This offers authors the opportunity to automatically transfer a rejected submission from one Elsevier journal to another Elsevier journal. 4. In this step, the editor carefully Once the editor has evaluated your manuscript, it could take a few weeks for the final decision. Among these patients, 79. Accept with minor revisions: Also known as conditional acceptance, this decision means that the paper requires minor changes for it to be accepted. Revise with ease: You have the opportunity to make necessary revisions to your submission. ; Search by keywords or journal title is designed to discover Decision; Revision; Proofing; Open Access; After Publication; accept or decline review invitations. Revise. The reviewing process may normally take from 4 to 10 weeks, although during the pandemic longer times are common. In the case of an When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. Your mileage may vary on that, but I guess at least for some journals, it doesn't mean what it *should* mean. It’s the quickest and easiest way to track your article's progress through the publication process. The process itself is extremely systematic, with assurances of rigor, fairness, and equity (to the extent that is possible). The status of my submission changed from "Under Review" to "Ready for Decision" on November 8 and it has been constant since then. The “Decision in process” status comes into the picture when the final decision is to be taken by the chief editor/editor-in-chief of the journal. Accept and Reject. This book emphasizes the importance of using and articulating clinical reasoning within The average number of days between the date of manuscript submission and date of receiving the editorial acceptance decision. The Editor-In-Chief or the Special Issue Editor of the journal must approve the recommended decision by GEs before informing the authors. On Jan 5, it turned again to 'Decision in Process' and now it is still stuck at this stage for nearly 2 weeks. If you are not on EM, go to your I have a paper which was invited to be resubmitted after minor revisions. The appeal must provide detailed evidence that the peer review process was flawed or that substantive factual errors were made by the reviewers and/or editors. At this stage when the journal decision is in process, the editor will go through the revised manuscript and your replies to the reviewer comments before coming to a decision. An acceptance at this stage is extremely rare. But how does the editor actually take the decision on a manuscript? This article If you have submitted your manuscript to an Editorial Manager journal but you have not yet received a final decision, you can check its status online. Usually the decision letter came quickly - in 3 days. On 25 Feb, the status again changed to "Editor declined invitation". The Editor has requested that you revise the submission. Then after 15 days, we received the first round of reviewer reports. Elsevier’s policy is to take a neutral position with respect to territorial disputes or jurisdictional claims, including, but not limited to, maps and institutional affiliations. 8% wished to be involved in making the decision to accept or not accept a liver for transplantation, 10. By: Alison McGonagle-O’Connell, Marketing Manager, Aries Systems Corporation Should the journal agree to reconsider the manuscript, acceptance is not guaranteed, and the reconsideration process may involve re-review by previous or new reviewers and/or Editors, decision in process elsevier acceptprince group zambrero. Is that a bad sign? The status date changes whenever someone does something to the paper. Peer review is an integral part of the publishing process, learn more about the peer review process, including: what the reviewer is looking for, the possible outcomes of peer review, common reasons for rejection, what to do if your manuscript is rejected, and how to respond to the reviewer comments. 0 days to accept manuscript. So, as mentioned previously, you may have reason to hope. 很不幸，一般来说，如果没有经历Reviewers invited（审稿人审稿）状态，直接进入Decision in process（决定）状态，说明编辑并没有将稿件分发给审稿人，而是自己直接做了决定，而这个决定一般是Reject（拒稿）。. In conclusion, it is essential to acknowledge that the review process can be a lengthy one, and multiple rounds of reviews and revisions may Elsevier respects the decisions taken by its authors as to how they choose to designate territories and identify their affiliations in their published content. Completed - Accept/Reject After your article has been reviewed, you will receive an email with a first decision on the article. The other status folders represent action needed by the corresponding If your paper has been accepted for publication, you can track it using Elsevier's Article Tracking service. As you may know too, the EIC’s decision is the final one. Unfortunately, rejecting manuscripts is part of your daily reality as editor. What might this imply? If it was intended to be rejected within the 10-day period, shouldn't they do so? That’s why, over the past six months, we have been increasingly taking the second approach to peer review. Now, I see that the paper is in "Decision in process". Skip to It includes research in Finally, the editor in Chief finalizes the decision. In conclusion, it is essential to acknowledge that the review process can be a lengthy Save time: Easily find other journals using suggestions based on input from journal editors, insights from our Scientific Editors, and matching algorithms. Plagiarism is often considered a classic form of scientific misconduct. So, a change to Decision in Process after the peer review means the Associate/Managing Editor (AE/ME) has looked at the reviewers’ comments, made their decision on the paper based on those comments, and has now referred the decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EIC). Completed - Accept/Reject When a journal displays the “decision in process” status, it means that the editorial board is in the process of making the final decision about your paper. At this point the status of your article will change to 'Completed' and no further modifications can be made in Editorial Manager. I had sent a paper to Elsevier. This journal follows a double anonymized review process. Accepted articles are automatically sent to the production department once the Editor has made a final decision of 'Accept'. This After resubmitting my revised manuscript on 20th of June, the status changed to 'under review' after only 4 days and then after 6 days (on 30th of June) it changed to 'required Once a paper is submitted to a journal, authors eagerly wait for the editorial decision. 2 Rational decision-making style, strategic thinking process and performance. My manuscript went from "With the Editor" to "Decision in Process" after I submitted it to a journal, which had a median decision time of 10 days. The Editor has made a decision and requested you revise the submission. You can also view bibliographic information When can I expect a decision from the Editor? Clinical Reasoning and Decision-Making Process: Child and Adolescent Assessment and Intervention presents an in-depth analysis by experienced psychologists on how to engage in clinical reasoning and decision making from assessment to intervention with children and youth. Proof Central always makes it possible for you to provide your corrections through an online mode. After one month, it still showed that it was with the editor, but with a different status date. Therefore, avoiding desk rejection implies that you have crossed the first big barrier. After revision, we submitted our revised manuscript (R1) on Dec 14, 2020. This streamlines the process of finding the most suitable journal for your manuscript. If your submission is deemed suitable, it will typically be sent to a minimum of two reviewers for an independent expert assessment of the scientific quality. I think it seems a long time for this step. Needing Revision’. I would write to the journal asking for The ‘decision in process’ status implies that your manuscript has passed through peer review and the editorial board is now making a decision. Please note, for To complete the decision, select a specific decision term from the drop-down menu at the top center of the page. Dear all, I submitted the revision of my manuscript two weeks ago. As an author, I’ve seen many AEs taking up to 2-3 weeks to make a decision regardless of the final outcome. It has been 3 weeks that the paper status stuck at decision in process. When a final decision has been made, your submission moves to the ‘ompleted’ menu. Decision in process: The handling editor has drafted a decision, but it has not yet been finalized or sent to the authors. Five days after submission, it showed that it was with the editor. If you are new to reviewing, welcome. Elsevier and Springer both usually take 6 weeks. Click Submissions with Required Reviews Complete on your main menu. Acceptance decisions Thank you for your question. g. It then discusses the various players involved in the peer review process, their role and what you as a reviewer are expected to do. I've got a paper that has been in "Decision in Process" for 3 weeks. If the metrics do not Coming to your query, Decision in Process typically means that the associate editor (AE) has gone through the peer review comments, arrived at a decision on the This article focuses on how to make a fair and relevant reject decision. Acceptance decisions on manuscripts can be made by the academic editor after peer review once a minimum of two review reports have been received. ' Is 8 days a long time to provide a final decision especially since the reviewers' responses were rather quick? Thank you for your answer. As the manuscript has gone for a peer review and then for a decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), indicated by the ‘Decision in Process’ status, you are concerned that the decision will be to reject – that’s why it’s not This article helps you understand what 'decision in process' means after you have submitted your paper to the journal. Please carefully review these guidelines before proceeding with the Special Issue process. If this a 'Reject and Transfer' type of decision and no previous editor has done so, you will be prompted to select target journals for the transfer offer before the Notify Author page appears. This may mean a rejection or it may mean a requirement to revise and resubmit. You will receive an email notice from the destination journal with a link to complete the submission process. This will be one of the following: Reject: Peer reviewers have reviewed the paper and do not find it suitable for publication To help authors find an alternative journal, we have our Elsevier Article Transfer Service (ATS) in place for the majority of our journals. This letter should give you any journal specific instructions for preparing the revision. You can use Journal Finder in two ways: Match my abstract is designed to suggest journals which have published articles with content similar to your manuscript. Now my manuscript is in the "Revision being processed" status. I have been sending a reminder almost once a month for these 5 months, but I just get a reply saying “we will ask the editor” every time and there has been no progress. Is that a bad sign? Respond to the invitation as soon as you can (even if it is to decline) — a delay in your decision slows down the review process and means more waiting for the author. In collaboration with HEADT Centre at Humboldt University, this Researcher Academy webinar discusses the different forms of text plagiarism However, if your paper was "With editor" and then "Decision in process" without "Under review," it might be a situation that, the AE does not think your paper is not enough qualified to be reviewed. I submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal on 13th April. Your submission will initially be assessed by our editors to determine suitability for publication in this journal. Respond to the invitation as soon as you can (even if it is to decline) — a delay in your decision slows down the review process and means more waiting for the author. ' Choose your reject decision term wisely - for the benefit of the author This is the fourth in a series of "tips & tricks" articles on making the review process easier and While specific rates vary between journals and subject fields, of course, across all Elsevier journals editors reject on average over 70% of submitted When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. These articles can help you find a journal to publish in, complete the publication of your academic, medical or scientific papers, and effectively avoid rejection of your paper. Key considerations include whether the manuscript fits the scope of the journal, the scientific content appears to be sound, the research was conducted ethically, and the writing This video covers the steps to take in Editorial Manager when setting the final disposition on a manuscript, following an "Accept" decision. Is there no choice but to keep just waiting? Decision in process: The handling editor has drafted a decision, but it has not yet been finalized or sent to the authors. Guidelines for authors Guidelines for reviewers Registered Reports are a form of empirical article offered at Learning & Instruction in which the 1. Completed Accept: If your manuscript is not accepted for publication in your chosen journal, you may receive an offer to transfer your submission to a more suitable journal, via Elsevier's Article Transfer Service (ATS). First of all, you have to wait for the minimum time to take final decision (that is generally 10-12 weeks for Elsevier). the highest-rank editor managing your paper) has started the process of submitting his/her decision. This phenomenon is an influential and well documented feature of human behaviour which has been studied in a Elsevier’s AI policy for book authors states that authors are allowed to use generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process before submission, but only to improve the language and readability of their work and with the appropriate disclosure, as per our instructions in Elsevier’s Guide for Authors. “Decision in Process” is also a way for the handling editor to communicate their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who makes the final decision on the manuscript. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? In such cases, it might show “Decision in Process” as the next status, and in all probability, the author will be informed of the rejection in a few days. Publishing in an Elsevier journal starts with finding the right journal for your paper. In this case you didn't see "Required Reviews This animated video provides a brief explanation of the various editorial statuses your submission may progress through in Editorial Manager. "Decision in progress" means all the reviews have already been received and what's left is for the editor to make a decision. If you are a seasoned reviewer looking to make certain you have dotted your “I”s and In Elsevier it is generally 21 or This is important to understand what causes a delay in decision process for submitted Choose good Journals they accept or reject your paper within Elsevier 저널 논문 심사 Decision in Process. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. Step-by-step guide for review process Requesting a review deadline extension Making changes to your completed review in Editorial Hi, I have submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal. A final decision to accept or reject the manuscript will be sent to the author along with any recommendations made by the referees, and may include verbatim comments by the referees. Follow these steps to consult your journal's 'Journal Insights' page: If you are on the EM site, click 'Journal Overview' in the top navigation bar to go directly to the journal's home page. 2 Weeks after getting my manuscript number. Decision in Process: This means that the editor is now taking a decision on your paper based on the peer reviewer comments and his/her own opinion. This often, but not always, changes the status. efore you begin the process, you can review the decision letter here to see what needs to be changed. This is not necessarily a bad outcome! It means you won't waste time on a review At the moment, the review process if over, and your paper will receive the first decision. Please note, for At one Elsevier journal, I have had a "Decision in Process" for about 7 weeks now (total time since submission over six months). If you are unable to access YouTube, you may watch this video on Bilibili (Chinese video sharing website). The following decision types are available: Reject; Major revision; Minor revision; Accept; Decisions are communicated to the corresponding author in a formal letter, along with reviewer feedback and any other requirements from the Once a paper is submitted to a journal, authors eagerly wait for the editorial decision. Before you begin Step-by-step guide for the review process, request extension of review deadline. 下面就这个问题，详细聊一聊SCI论文投递完成后，不同阶段投稿系统中的状态一栏的提示 Dear all, I submitted the revision of my manuscript two weeks ago. For these My paper is now decision in process for over two weeksa after second revision ( 2 reviewers accept, 1 reviewer major revision). The decisions of JOGNN’s editors are final. How. In Elsevier, particularly, before this happens, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. But one day later I received another notice saying the lastest decision has been rescind and returned to the previous status. Follow instructions from the selected journal: Shortly after the transfer confirmation, Elsevier or the selected journal will send you an email asking you to sign in and continue with your submission process. After 5 weeks it's now decision in These submissions undergo a two-phase review process in which study rationale and methodology are considered prior to the research being undertaken. If you were not previously registered as a user in the destination journal, you will be automatically registered. Even if your paper does not get accepted, it is indeed a big deal that you will be getting peer reviewer comments as these will help improve your paper and take it a step closer to publication. Please share with the community how many days the entire process took by the editor's office. 6% did not want to be involved in the decision-making process. After going through the reviewers’ comments, the editor will make a decision about your manuscript. Completed - Accept/Reject In Elsevier, particularly, before this happens, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. Follow instructions from the selected journal: Shortly When editors make a final decision on a manuscript, the decision and reviewer comments are sent in a letter to the corresponding author. For marginal and R&Rs, I normally take 2-5 days. In evaluating an organisation's performance and the uncertainties of the environment that influences the complexities in achieving positive growth for the organisation successfully, managers must have decision-making skills that utilise strategic thinking processes. Instances of this decision are also rather rare. Now, after 35 days, the status has changed from With Editor to Decision Under Process. In case of a rejection, an article transfer will be considered. I have submitted a manuscript to a journal published by Elsevier and the status on the Elsevier Edoitorial System (EES) changed from "With editor" to "Decision in process" 5 days ago. The peer review process acts as a filter to ensure only good research is Respond to the invitation as soon as you can (even if it is to decline) — a delay in your decision slows down the review process and means more waiting for the author. It took ages to carry out the process and finally they rejected my paper for the reason that they are Decision in process - The handling editor has entered a decision but the decision is not yet finalized and has not been sent to the We accept scientifically rigorous research, regardless In Elsevier, particularly, before this happens, the status of the article shows Decision in Process. The editor makes his/her final decision after evaluating the peer review reports. When a paper receives a minor revision decision, it might not be sent for a second round of peer review; usually, the editor goes through the revisions and Respond to the invitation as soon as you can (even if it is to decline) — a delay in your decision slows down the review process and means more waiting for the author. Decision in process - The handling editor has entered a decision but the decision is not yet finalized and has not been sent to the We accept scientifically rigorous research, regardless of novelty. From the editorial manager account, we can see that the status of our revised manuscript is "Under Review" and it remains unchanged from Jan 02, Register and Select New Reviewer: Begins the process of registering a new reviewer; you must have the person's email address, name, and country to complete the process. Once a manuscript has passed an initial submission check, editors must assess its content to determine whether it is suitable for peer review. ’ :-) To respond to your queries until then, it’s a bit unusual that the revised manuscript (for a minor revision decision) has gone to Under Review, which Thank you for your question. org within 30 days of receipt of the decision. I thought it is a desk rejection but shouldn’t the decision have been sent already? Why is it taking all that time to inform the corresponding author of the editor’s decision? Could I have If your manuscript is not accepted for publication in your chosen journal, you may receive an offer to transfer your submission to a more suitable journal, via Elsevier's Article Transfer Service (ATS). IOP has a range of different decisions you could receive and these are outlined below. This may include enhancing, obscuring, moving, removing, or introducing a In my field (Linguistics), it's getting rare and rare to get "accepted with minor/major revision". The Editorial Office may also provide this letter to reviewers so that you know the final status of the paper and can see other reviewer’s feedback. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? Among these patients, 79. My question is how long does it take for this status to change under an ideal situation? ‘Revisions eing Processed’ until a decision is made. The submission process has completed with either an Accept or Reject decision. As the corresponding author, if you are offered the option to transfer your submission to another journal, a new menu appears for ‘Pending Submission Transfer Offers’. Every year, we accept and publish more than 470,000 journal articles. Decision in process means tgat all reviewers submitted their report and the AE is in the process of making a decision. You can submit to most Elsevier journals using an online system, either the Elsevier The journal editor will make a first decision about your the journal, the editor will send your manuscript to one or more reviewers – experts in your field. After you accept a transfer offer, you must now log into the new journal and complete the submission process. This status will remain until you begin the process of submitting your revision. I had e-mailed the journal manager enquiring about the "with editor " status. Final decision: The editor has received the peer review reports and has made a final decision; Possible Decisions. To turn them on, please click on the gear icon at the bottom of the video player and select your preferred language. What does this mean? are an essential part of the publishing process, so we have created this resource for both new and experienced reviewers. Becoming a Referee for Design To give the author another opportunity to accept a Transfer Offer, use Rescind Decision and then make a new Transfer decision. Again, on September 28, the status was ‘Under review’. The editor makes his/her final decision after evaluating the Confirmation email: After confirming the transfer, you will receive an email from Elsevier with a copy of the confirmed transfer details. There are four possible decision options for the Editor. With the support of peer review and an opportunity to It is up to the editor whether to accept or reject. Does this mean it got sent to reviewers or the editor is evaluating it? Any experience here? It’s an Elsevier journal. Can I anticipate rejection? How long should I wait for this stage? 2. We will guide you through the review process, as it may initially appear to be an unstructured task. pbvbnzxhegotalrgmomudquctcxdhaqpsicmhgsduqxigpmxgmgm